Hungry Yet Humble

A blog about entrepreneurship from the front lines of a growing startup 
« Back to blog

Defining The 5 Classes of Entrepreneurs

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about what makes a great entrepreneur and the motivations behind why someone tries to become one.  People have been asking me for advice on starting companies or raising money, and I’ve been giving talks at various events about my humble experiences as an entrepreneur.  I found myself often struggling to answer broad questions and provide blanket statements about what works and what doesn’t work, without some sort of “situational context”.  By situational context, I mean if you’re trying to start the next Google or if you want to start a new shoe company.  After a bit of thought, I’ve come to the conclusion that there are really 5 “classes” of entrepreneurship with different motivations for each.  I hope to spur some discussion on the topic, so I’ll dive right in:

The Five Classes of Entrepreneurs

I. Opportunist – Class I Entrepreneur
II. Lifestyle Entrepreneur – Class II Entrepreneur
III. Problem Solver – Class III Entrepreneur
IV. Visionary – Class IV Entrepreneur
V. Game Changer – Class V Entrepreneur

Maybe I’ve been hearing too much talk about “Magic the Gathering” cards in the office lately, but I organized the “types” of entrepreneur into Classes.  In my opinion each “class” represents a different level of goal, motivation, and outcome, and it is certainly possible for people to progress from one level to another.

I. The Opportunist Entrepreneur (Class I): The Opportunist recognizes that a particular situation presents an opportunity to make money and goes for it.  The opportunity could be selling umbrellas on a rainy day, offering ice cold bottles of water in the middle of summer, or jumping on a hot and timely trend and offering some sort of related service.  Many entrepreneurs get their start this way, as the best “opportunistic” opportunities often do not require much start up capital and often have a sense of urgency about them.

An experience I had as an Opportunist was during college.  It was the early 90’s, and people were using usenet newsgroups as the web was still in the lynx/mosaic phase.  I was a big fan of sportscards (baseball cards etc) and recognized an opportunity to take sportscard inventory from local card dealers for teams and athletes that were locally not in demand (eg. 49ers cards in Boston don’t often sell well) and sell them over the Internet.  I was able to pay for a lot of my college expenses with this little hobby business.  My desire to start a website that would enable me and my friends to trade goods online is a whole other story, however :)
Skill required: 3 / Endurance required: 2 / Foresight: 4

II. The Lifestyle Entrepreneur (Class II): The Lifestyle entrepreneur wants to build a business to be his or her own boss, work with his or her friends/family, or pursue an engaging but not all-consuming business opportunity while still maintaining balance in ones life.  Many Lifestyle businesses are bootstrapped to begin with, because if there was outside funding in the business, there would often be outside pressure to build the business faster or achieve some sort of a financial exit.  A lifestyle entrepreneur could be doing anything from running a successful (and fun) restaurant to operating a software business.  Perhaps the critical defining characteristic about a lifestyle business is that it is run to solve for the benefit of work / life balance or personal gratification rather than for growth.

I worked for a Lifestyle Entrepreneur once and it was an eye opening experience where I learned about people’s different motivations and goals.  I personally can totally respect people who seek lifestyle business balance.  How much money does a person really need?  And at the same time, not everyone wants to be retired at 35, so why not try to do stimulating or fun work and still get to play around as well.
Requirements: sustainable business; life goals.

III. Problem Solver (Class III): The Problem Solver case starts with a person who can’t seem to get his/her mind off a problem until they’ve figured out a way to solve it.  And then they cross into becoming a Class III entrepreneur when they resolve to do something about it.  Many companies get their initial start with the goal of solving 1 problem.  This fact is significant.  To me, when friends or friends of friends ask me about business ideas or starting companies, and they have all these different ideas or solutions thought up – I get concerned. Pick one problem and start from there.  If you can solve that problem (and enough people have that problem) then you’ll likely have a business of some sort.  

Visible Measures got started this way.  When we sort of figured out a problem we wanted to attack (understanding user behavior) we narrowed it down to the field of online video as a way to hopefully be able to build up some traction and expertise.  To get going as a problem solver takes focus; to create and grow a problem solving business takes all of the traits of an entrepreneur.
Defining trait: Hunger for improvement

IV. Visionary (Class IV): The Visionary thinks they can see the future, a future world that is more efficient or more open or more collaborative.  Since the Internet first rose from academic curiosity to phenomenon to business critical infrastructure, there are been several visionary companies who were ahead of the curve including Napster (P2P and freedom of music), 6Degrees (social linking), Altavista (parallel search), Friendster (social networking), and Second Life (virtual worlds).  All of these companies share several common traits: strong visionary entrepreneurial roots, game changing impact and potential, and a struggle to cross the chasm into long term viability.  In some ways, the Visionary does the most to help the entrepreneurial community because so many of us draft behind the trailblazers who innovate and forge ahead in front of us.  
Legacy: The world (or at least people’s perception of what is possible in it) has changed.

V. Game-changer (Class V): The game-changers are the entrepreneurs that we read about every day, and are often people long-admired by students and fans of business innovation.  For me, I have always been amazed by the accomplishments and drive of leaders like Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Michael Dell, Larry Ellison, and others.  Not withstanding whatever debate there may be about a person’s or company’s business practices, Class V entrepreneurs have not only taken products, technologies and even industries to another level on the innovation curve, the ones I respect the most have done it day in and day out for years.  Larry & Sergey are now in these ranks and Mark Z. is definitely on his way. 

To me, a critical factor in going from Class IV to Class V Enterpreneur is the notion of "sustained innovation".  To burn brightly only to flame out a few years later doesn't make the cut in my opinion.  If Facebook has 500 million members a few years from now and is the dominant social networking platform on the planet, then Mark Z has clearly achieved "game-changer" status. 

I think about how Steve Jobs once said that the death is the destination we all share – so “have the courage to follow your heart and intuition. They somehow already know what you truly want to become. Everything else is secondary.”
Longevity: At least a decade of sustained innovation. Impact: Wow.

Those are the 5 classes of Entrepreneurs that I came up with.  I’m curious to hear what you think.

And as Steve Jobs once said: Stay Hungry.  Stay Foolish.

(or try to be “hungry yet humble”)

- Brian

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (17)

Feb 20, 2009
 said...
Hey, Brian, if I want to cast Level IV visionary, should I tap 2 land or burn up my extra mana? (It is very hard to make fun of Magic when I've never played it.)

I wrote something about class V level phenoms in this facebook post I made a while back:
http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=2235830149&id=701156&index=14

Feb 20, 2009
 said...
Nice taxonomy (well, list :)
I would say right now I fall into Class III and Class IV.
Which are very much destructive to Class II :)
Feb 21, 2009
robgo said...
Nice post Brian! I do wonder how much the transition from #3 - #4 is dependent on the entrepreneur vs the business they have started. Personally, I think #3 and #4 are more or less the same. The distinction is more the scale of the problem they have chosen to solve, and whether their solution anticipates the way customers and technology are likely to evolve. I do agree with you that what distinguishes class 5 from others is sustained innovation. But that is pretty rarefied air.
Feb 21, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Rob,

Great question! I think the distinction between a "Problem Solver" and a "Visionary" is the scope at which they hope to have an impact. My first startup I co-founded help route customer service email more efficiently so that customer service reps for high traffic websites could process more email in a day. That is a clear problem, but didn't have the potential to really re-frame an industry, so I think of that as a problem-solving experience and not as a visionary one.

what do you think?

brian

Feb 21, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Roy,

it's great to hear from you. I agree that you're falling into class III and class IV entrepreneurial behavior. Going.com is the bomb man! Since i'm so old, seems like the only time I go to a bar is via a going.com event :)

Feb 22, 2009
Fernando Lopez said...
Hey Brian, nice list! I've been thinking for a while also that not all entrepreneurs are created equal (although there is room for all). This puts some strucutre to that. One question, in what class would you place the entrepreneur who is primarily driven by the love or passion for their type of business? It could be the baking company started by someone who has a passion for cooking. Or the conflict facilitation company started by someone who has a passion for collaboration and constructive conflict. Or of course, the technology company for someone who has a passion for technology.

I wouldn't place them under "lifestyle" entrepreneurs because they're often so passionate that balance goes out the window. They may become visionaries and game-changers, but they don't start out that way. Would you create another class between III and IV, called "Passion-driven"?

Cheers,
Fernando

Feb 22, 2009
mikewat said...
How would you classify serial entrepreneurs? Type 1 seems most fitting, though they do this for life so Type 2? Most try to solve problems. Type 3? Many are very visionary. Type 4? Some are game changing for sure.
Feb 22, 2009
 said...
I went in to business thinking that I was a class V, changing my expectations to a class III as I got to know my market better and then spending a lot of time acting as a class I to generate revenue.

Is that because I was unsuccessful or because I began with unrealistic expectations and then grew up?

Feb 22, 2009
pamelateagarden said...
Love, love, love this post.

It has been fun to watch the definition of 'entrepreneur' change over the years. As it broadens, the world is changing. (or is that vice versa?) In this recession, I am sure that so many people who would have never, in a million years, thought of themselves as entrepreneurs... will become more entrepreneurial out of sheer 'need' for transition. Yea!

In my practice, I have a tool that can profile an individual's entrepreneurial behaviors according to 12 dimensions. That gives a story of 'how'.

Now, having read your fabulous post, I am thinking quite a bit more about the 'what' and the 'why'.

Thank you for allowing me to learn from you.

Pam Teagarden
www.teagardengroup.com

Feb 22, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Fernando - great to hear from you - it's been too long. I have thought about the "passionate" entrepreneurs and I think that I would have to put that among the motivations for entrepreneurship, not the classes.

I think that the type of person you describe who loves baking is either a problem solver or a visionary - in either case, to be successful they must be doing something new, more efficient, or better. I will write another article about the motivations of the entrepreneur.

Feb 22, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Mikewat - I think that serial entrepreneurs often "climb up the ladder" so to speak. Some may start with a simple Opportunistic (Class I) situation - such as selling T shirts with the Obama Hope icon on front during the inauguration, and may progress to doing something with a larger potential scope later.

I will write another post about motivations soon, but I think that serial entrepreneurs are motivated to try something new (new industry, new problem, new type of organization, new scope of opportunity) or to fulfill some other as yet unmet need. Progressing from one class of entrepreneur to the next is often one of the motivations.

Feb 22, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Matthew Cain - I think that the type of behavior you are describing where you have had to adjust your expectations and goals depending on the obstacles is noteworthy and commendable. One of the most-oft-cited traits of successful entrepreneurs is Adaptability. Sometimes you have to "survive before you can thrive".

In economic times like these, often companies that can figure out creative ways to survive will be those who will in the end emerge strong enough to thrive later.

I wouldn't think of yourself as "not successful". Everyone has their own measurement standard for success. If you can survive and set your company up to thrive later, that sounds successful to me.

Feb 22, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Pam, I checked out your website - teagarden groups looks really interesting and I like what I read about "Basis", it really does sound like it gives a framework for figuring out the "how". Hope we can have more dialog in the coming months. I will post some more articles related this one to hopefully build a bit on it.

thank you so much for your interest,

brian

Feb 23, 2009
pauldyson said...
Nice post. I'm fundamentally a Class II; my motto is "do good work with good people for good money ... and have a good life at the same time". But I find that I shift types over time, usually returning to Class II behaviour eventually. So my first business was definitely set up in a Class I way - there was a great opportunity and we took it. Recently I left my second business (after eight years) to take a bit of a sabbatical and already I have a Class III problem that I'm itching to solve.

Do you think 'serial entrepreneurs' or 'self sufficient entrepreneurs' (people who are always starting and running businesses without necessarily looking to sell up and retire at the first opportunity) shift classes as a matter of routine?

Feb 23, 2009
Brian Shin said...
Paul, great comments and question! I think that successful entrepreneurs, those who can either start/build a sustainable business, have to switch as a matter of course, depending on their company's needs.

We hear about people who sell their businesses for a ton of money, but there are literally millions of entrepreneurs who are successful by many measures, though they do not sell their businesses. I think that out of those self-sufficient entrepreneurs, all classes are probably represented.

You could cite Craig Newmark from Craiglist.org an example of this. He may or may never sell out, but he's built a tremendous business (and has been a lot more capitalistic than the "he's such a non-greedy guy!" media coverage gives him credit for). I would probably characterize him as a Class IV Visionary at the onset (especially for his ideals and vision for what kind of ideals the company would have).

In many ways, he has translated into a game-changer, as Craigslist has changed the way people connect with each other locally, and has been doing so for years. People have been predicting their displacement by a new entrant for years, but they keep chugging along.

Feb 23, 2009
Marc Dangeard said...
there is another kind I think, The Artist - from Bo Burlingham's book:
[...] there is obviously a kind of artistry involved in creating something out of nothing based on an ability to see what everyone else is missing. That is, after all, what artists do. In business as in art, moreover, the end result is an experience, and the quality of the experience reflects the relationships between different participants, as well as the specific medium of expression. While entrepreneurs may rely on peripheral vision rather than artistic inspiration, it's often hard to tell the difference between the two. They are both critical components of a creative process, and it takes such a process to produce something great an unique [...]
Aug 04, 2009
ginidietrich said...
Brian - great post! @jamesIII sent it to me because I wrote a blog post today (http://su.pr/1rAh4m) about becoming a Level 5 CEO. I've been pondering the idea for a few days and started a list of what I think it looks like for me. But you've made it MUCH more clear. Thank you!!

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     twitter